Blog

Can a Pre-Existing Injury Hurt Your Car Accident Claim in Virginia?

Maybe your back was already hurt before the crash. The question now is whether it hurts more, limits you in new ways, or requires treatment you did not need before. When you have a pre-existing injury, a car accident claim is not automatically barred in Virginia simply because you had the prior condition.

Virginia law allows compensation when a collision aggravates an existing condition or makes the accident-related injury more severe or harder to treat, although you cannot recover for the underlying condition itself. The Law Firm of Carlton F. Bennett, P.L.L.C. can help you evaluate what changed after the crash and what evidence may support your claim.

How Can a Pre-Existing Injury Affect a Virginia Car Accident Claim?

Virginia law does not require you to have been in perfect health before a car accident. If the crash worsened an injury or condition you already had, you may still recover for the additional harm it caused.

The key is separating what existed before the collision from what changed afterward. A prior condition can fall into one of three categories:

• It stayed essentially the same. The other driver is not responsible for a condition that the crash did not worsen.
• The crash aggravated it. If your symptoms, limitations, or need for treatment increased because of the collision, that worsening may be compensable.
• It made the new injury worse. A pre-existing condition may also make an accident-related injury more severe or harder to treat, and Virginia law allows that added harm to be considered.

Virginia’s civil jury instructions specifically allow compensation for aggravation and for increased severity or difficulty of treatment, but not for the pre-existing condition itself.

In other words, pre-existing conditions in a car accident claim do not automatically erase a valid injury claim. Compensation is tied to the harm caused by the collision, not to the condition as it existed beforehand. That is why a pre-existing injury aggravated in a car accident often becomes a before-and-after question: What could you do before the crash? What symptoms and treatment did you have? And what materially changed afterward?

How Do You Show That a Car Accident Made an Existing Injury Worse?

If there is a pre-existing injury, a car accident claim often turns on evidence showing what your condition looked like before the collision and how it changed afterward. The goal is not to pretend the earlier condition never existed. It is to separate the old problem from the additional harm caused by the crash.

Useful evidence may include:

• Prior medical records. These can show your symptoms, treatment, and limitations before the collision.
• Post-crash treatment. New appointments, medication changes, therapy, injections, surgery, or other treatment may help document a change.
• Changes in daily function. Greater difficulty working, driving, sleeping, exercising, or handling ordinary tasks may show how the condition worsened.
• Medical findings. Examinations, diagnostic testing, and medical opinions may help connect new or increased problems to the crash.

Virginia places the burden on the plaintiff to prove that the defendant’s negligence caused the damages being claimed. That makes a clear medical and functional timeline especially useful when the same body part was already causing problems before the accident.

Why Do Insurance Companies Focus on Pre-Existing Conditions?

Old medical records can help either side of a car accident claim. An insurer may use them to argue that your present symptoms were already there, but the same records may help you show exactly what changed after the crash.

For example, the insurer may compare:

• Were your symptoms the same before and after the crash? The insurer may review whether the same complaints were documented before the collision.
• Were you already receiving treatment for the condition? The insurer may compare your earlier treatment history with the treatment you needed after the crash.
• Did the crash change what you could do? The records may show whether you could work, exercise, drive, or handle daily tasks more easily before the collision.
• Does your account match the medical record? The insurer may compare what you report about the prior injury with what your earlier records actually document.

Those comparisons can help show whether the crash caused a new injury or made an existing condition meaningfully worse. That is why pre-existing conditions in a car accident claim should be addressed accurately rather than hidden or minimized. A record showing that an old condition was stable or required little treatment may help establish that the collision caused a meaningful change.

If litigation puts your physical condition at issue, Virginia law permits disclosure of relevant medical information through the legal process. It does not make a claimant’s entire medical history automatically relevant.

Get a Clear Picture of What the Crash Changed

When an insurer cites an old injury, the key is to show what your health and daily life looked like before the collision and what changed afterward. Carlton Bennett has spent decades handling serious injury claims and has built a trusted reputation helping injured Virginians. The Law Firm of Carlton F. Bennett, P.L.L.C. can review your medical history, explain how Virginia law applies, and help you determine your next step. Contact us to schedule a free consultation.

FAQs About Pre-Existing Injuries and Virginia Car Accident Claims

Can I Still File a Car Accident Claim in Virginia If I Had a Pre-Existing Injury?

Yes. A prior injury does not bar a claim. The key is whether the collision caused a new injury, aggravated the earlier condition, or made accident-related harm more severe or harder to treat.

How Do Insurance Companies Use Pre-Existing Injuries to Deny Car Accident Claims In Virginia?

An insurer may argue that your current symptoms or treatment came from the earlier condition rather than the crash. Before-and-after medical and functional evidence can help address that dispute.

What Is Aggravation of a Pre-Existing Injury in a Virginia Car Accident Case?

Aggravation means the collision made an existing condition worse. Virginia allows compensation for the worsening or added severity, not for the condition as it existed before the crash.

How Does Virginia’s Contributory Negligence Law Affect a Pre-Existing Injury Claim?

These are separate issues. A pre-existing injury concerns the harm the crash caused or worsened. Virginia’s contributory negligence rule asks whether your own negligence helped cause the collision. A prior medical condition is not itself contributory negligence, but negligence that proximately caused the crash can bar recovery in Virginia.

How Much Is a Pre-Existing Injury Car Accident Settlement Worth in Virginia?

There is no fixed average pre-existing injury settlement. Value depends on the severity and duration of the aggravation, added treatment or limitations, lost income, liability, available insurance, and the strength of the evidence linking the added harm to the crash.

Legal References Used to Inform This Page

To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal resources during the content development process:

• Virginia Model Jury Instructions—Civil, Instructions Nos. 3.050, 9.010, and 9.030 (Release 26, April 2026)
• Virginia Code § 8.01-399—Communications Between Physicians and Patients
• RGR, LLC v. Settle, Record No. 130633 (Supreme Court of Virginia, Oct. 31, 2014)